In 1916, the John Lane Company of New York published Impressions of the Art at the Panama-Pacific Exposition by the art critic Christian Brinton. Amongst the 105 entries in the bibliography, Brinton lists thirteen books published by Paul Elder & Company. Eight of the thirteen titles are familiar to us, but there are no known copies of the other five. What happened to them?
The five mystery Elder titles are:
- The Dream City, its Art in Story and Symbolism, by Rose V. S. Berry
- Storied Walls of the Exposition, by Katherine Delmar Burke
- Illustrated Record of the Exposition, by Louis C. Mullgardt and A. Stirling Calder
- The Critical Review of the Exposition, in two volumes, by Eugen Neuhaus
- A Record of the Panama-Pacific International Exposition, by Eugen Neuhaus, Louis C. Mullgardt, and A. Stirling Calder
Two of these books were in fact published, but not by Elder. The Dream City, by Rose Virginia Stewart Berry, was published in 1915 by Walter N. Brunt, a printing shop at 5th & Mission in San Francisco. Storied Walls of the Exposition, by Katherine Delmar Burke, was evidently self-published by the author in 1915; no printer or publisher is listed in the book itself. For the other three titles, I can find no record anywhere other than in Brinton’s bibliography. (It’s possible that the “two volumes” of The Critical Review of the Exposition refer to Neuhaus’s two books that Elder did publish, The Art of the Exposition and The Galleries of the Exposition, especially given that Galleries is subtitled “A Critical Review of the Paintings, Statuary and the Graphic Arts in the Palace of Fine Arts at the Panama-Pacific International Exposition.” On the other hand, Art and Galleries are also listed separately in Brinton’s bibliography.)
Brinton’s book was published in 1916, after the Exposition had closed. It’s curious, then, why he cites Stella Perry’s Little Bronze Playfellows, a well-known Elder published in 1915, under the erroneous title Little Bronze Playfellows of the Fine Arts Colonnade. One possibility is that Brinton had begun compiling his bibliography in early 1915, when Elder’s publication plans still included all thirteen titles and Little Bronze Playfellows still had the longer working title. Under this theory, Brinton then went ahead with publication in 1916 without circling back to double-check the accuracy of Elder’s offerings.
As to why Elder chose not to publish these five titles, the answer almost certainly lies with his underlying financial difficulties. After the 1906 earthquake and fire destroyed his bookstore and the Tomoye Press, Elder moved to New York City in an attempt to restart the Press in the nerve center of American publishing. Unfortunately, delays and increased expenses left him with unsold inventory and serious debts. Elder returned to San Francisco in 1909, but the leftover debts dogged him for many years.
Christian Brinton (1870-1942) was born in West Chester, Pennsylvania, near Philadelphia. He was an authority on Russian and Soviet contemporary art, and amassed an impressive collection of Russian and Soviet Art which he donated to the Philadelphia Museum of Art. He knew Leon Trotsky when Trotsky was an obscure newspaper reporter in New York City in 1917, and was a close friend of Anatol Lunacharsky, Soviet Commissar of Education and Art and later Soviet Ambassador to Spain. He had famous friends in many parts of Europe, and was decorated by King Gustav of Sweden in 1917 and by King Albert of Belgium in 1931.1New York Times, 15 July 1942, p15. Accessed 28 Oct 2026.
- 1New York Times, 15 July 1942, p15. Accessed 28 Oct 2026. ↩︎
























